16 February 2013 Saturday
Columnists 22 August 2011, Monday 0 0 0 0

A buffer zone with Syria in the works

In the last National Security Council (MGK) meeting held on Aug. 18, members of this top decision-making body on national security matters discussed the possibility of establishing a “buffer zone” along the Syrian border in case there is a wave of refugees fleeing in droves to the Turkish side.

In a nearly five-hour-long deliberation, the contingency planning for a buffer zone was studied carefully and drawn up upon the possibility that the Bashar Al-Assad regime will likely fail to stem violence in the turbulent country. All hell will break loose when Syria destabilizes and a civil war starts that is fought along ethnic and sectarian fault lines, sending millions of Syrians to the Turkish border to seek safe haven. That is why Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan described what has been happening in Syria since March as very much an “internal affair of Turkey.”


Turks still remembers the aftermath of the first Gulf War during which almost a million Iraqi Kurds flocked to Turkey following Saddam's crackdown in northern Iraq. It caught Turkish authorities unprepared and created numerous problems within Turkey. Ankara did not repeat the same mistake in the second Iraq war when it drew up plans to create buffer zones inside Iraq, using already established military outposts there as logistical command centers. Thankfully, it did not come to that as Saddam fought the battle mostly in central and southern Iraq, while Kurds enjoyed the protection provided by the US-led coalition in the north.


In the present case, the buffer zone would be set up first in the “no man's land” between the Syrian and Turkish lines of demarcation and would be extended further into Syrian territory if needed. Considering that the width of the no man's land on the Turkish side varies from 300 to 1,000 meters along the Syrian border, the possibility of extending it onto Syrian soil is quite likely. What is more, there is not much of an alternative as to where to set up these refugee centers as most of the 877-kilometer-long border still remains heavily mined. There are some pockets of the border areas where mines were cleared by both sides and are available to use. But that would not be enough.


The good news is that most of the land near the border falls under the legal category of “Forbidden Military Zone,” meaning that the Turkish Armed Forces (TSK) supervises the public land. Some of this land was farmland before and owned by private parties, but it was all nationalized during the 1956 demarcation. The TSK has cleared mines from some of this land, but most of it remains heavily mined. According to Turkey's commitments to Ottawa mine treaty obligations, all these mines should be cleared by 2014, which seems highly unlikely at the current pace. Amazingly, Syrian farmers took it upon themselves to clear mines in the fertile buffer zone, totaling 250 million square meters, and planted cotton and olive trees.


As many restive towns in Syria located in the north are close to the Turkish border, the risk is greater for Ankara than other neighboring countries in the east and the south, i.e., Iraq and Jordan. The Turkish policy of open borders also differs from others as we saw in the June refugee crisis. "Turkey is the sole country to declare an open border policy. This is indeed a very impressive operational approach," Carol Batchelor, United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR), said of Turkey at the time.


In a way, Turkey ran drills during the June crisis that saw over 10,000 Syrians who fled from violence to seek safe haven in Turkey. It was a small-scale operation and was manageable on its own, but the refugee crisis looming on the horizon would dwarf what we saw back then and will undoubtedly require massive contingency planning. Officials from the Prime Ministry's Disaster and Emergency Management Directorate (AFAD) are telling us that they are ready to immediately mobilize to respond to a wave of refugees crossing the border as well as to evacuate Turkish citizens and foreign nationals stuck in the violence in Syria. AFAD received much praise for handling evacuations from Egypt and Libya earlier this year.


To claim legitimacy and dismiss accusations of hostile intentions, Turkey would likely pursue this approach in coordination with international and regional bodies. International law, especially articles and additional protocols of the 1949 Geneva Conventions as well as the newly developed UN doctrine of the Responsibility to Protect (R2P), certainly allows Turkey to take action to protect civilians during the conflict. Though Turkey will take the lead and initiative, any buffer zone would likely be operated with the UNHCR with members from the Organization of Islamic Cooperation (OIC), the Arab League and the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) pitching in, either by committing manpower or providing financial resources.


This would be first and foremost a humanitarian obligation on Turkey's part and should not be confused with anything else. Designated buffer zones would help reduce casualties in heavily mined border areas. In the absence of buffer zones, Syrians would nonetheless push across border areas where it might be dangerous. As such, buffer zones would remove the need to attempt hazardous journeys and alleviate concerns at least to some extent in what otherwise would be seen as a catastrophic humanitarian crisis.


Lest Damascus adopt the “scorched-earth-policy” with respect to civilians in border areas, Turkey, with Europe's largest army, would have no problem in providing firepower to protect and secure refugee centers. We all know what happened in so-called safe havens in Bosnia, Rwanda and northern Iraq where hundreds and thousands were butchered despite promises of protection from the UN or occupying powers. Turks do not want anything like this on their conscience and will do everything in their power to prevent the Assad regime from going after fleeing refugees.


The younger Assad should recall how Turkey, frustrated with the terror originating in its southern neighbor, threatened military action against his country in the late 1990s during which he was busy climbing up the military ranks to replace his older brother, Basil, who unexpectedly died in a car crash, forcing his father Assad to nominate the junior Assad, his only son, as the rightful heir. Like father, son Assad knows very well that Turkey means business and that it does not fool around.


It is true that Turkish officials have openly said they are against establishing buffer zones along the Syrian border, and we have reported what they said in this newspaper. Considering that Ankara does not want this crisis to escalate into a full-blown civil war, statements like these were not unexpected at all. However, that does not mean Turks are naïve and have no fallback positions whatsoever when push comes to shove. Let's just pray it never comes to that.

Columnists Previous articles of the columnist
15 February 2013
France courts better ties with Turkey
11 February 2013
US Ambassador Ricciardone's blunder
8 February 2013
Why is Turkey sending its navy to Somalia?
4 February 2013
US response to embassy attack
1 February 2013
Engaging in Africa without challenging others
21 January 2013
Steps to align Turkey with ECtHR
18 January 2013
Whistleblower reveals foreign policy blunders in Turkey
14 January 2013
Turkey and hydrocarbons in Iraq
11 January 2013
The PKK bookkeeper and cover-up
7 January 2013
Turkey's security deals with partner nations
4 January 2013
DPG's challenge to secret US-Iran talks on Afghanistan
31 December 2012
US secret talks with Iran over Afghanistan
28 December 2012
New tool to promote trade
24 December 2012
Sudan and South Sudan: indispensable partners for Turkey
21 December 2012
Failure of new constitution in Turkey
17 December 2012
Turkey tightens vise on tax havens
14 December 2012
Turkey to help secure Af-Pak border
10 December 2012
Turkey, Hungary should do more
7 December 2012
Last act for Assad
3 December 2012
Turkey's golden story with Iran
30 November 2012
Connecting Turks and Emiratis
26 November 2012
Israel's legal woes in Palestine
23 November 2012
Turkey's new plan on Cyprus property disputes
19 November 2012
Turkey should arm the opposition in Syria
16 November 2012
Turkey's high hopes for Africa
12 November 2012
Turkey, Brunei offer promising partnership
9 November 2012
Turkey slacking on combating terrorism financing
5 November 2012
Fouling up press freedom in Turkey
2 November 2012
Rapprochement with Israel unlikely
29 October 2012
Phone call that disrupted Turkey's ties with Iraq
22 October 2012
Future of Afghanistan and Turkey's role
18 October 2012
De-coupling fears for Turkey-Russia ties over Syria
15 October 2012
Iran to turn ECO into paper organization
12 October 2012
The pro-war lobby rallies in Turkey
8 October 2012
EU ‘regress report' 2012
5 October 2012
New mandate needed for diplomats, not military
1 October 2012
Elections and a swelling budget in Turkey
28 September 2012
Convention speech and Erdoğan's dream
24 September 2012
Iran prime culprit for slashed hajj quotas
21 September 2012
Role of Iran and Syria in THKP/C terrorism against Turkey
17 September 2012
Early warning for Muslim bashing
14 September 2012
Campaign to repatriate stolen Turkish artifacts
9 September 2012
Iran's terror and trade war against Turkey
7 September 2012
Turkey hails Egypt's comeback
3 September 2012
Turkey's management of Syrian refugee crisis
31 August 2012
Germany playing dangerous game with Muslims
27 August 2012
Turkey's Myanmar policy
24 August 2012
Prosecuting Syrians in Turkish courts
17 August 2012
Wait on Syria, push for Kandil
13 August 2012
New page in Syria
10 August 2012
Countering Iran's threat
6 August 2012
Iran Spring and Turkey
3 August 2012
Turkey to shape Syrian army in post-Assad era
30 July 2012
The new CHP vigor for Turkish politics
27 July 2012
Turkey's play with Syrian Kurds
6 July 2012
Scorecard for Turkey's AK Party since election victory
2 July 2012
Turkey and Arab anxiety
29 June 2012
Iran, Syria to target Turkish troops in Lebanon
25 June 2012
Is Turkey itching for war with Syria?
22 June 2012
Sledgehammer case and ECtHR
18 June 2012
EU presidency of Greek Cyprus: Coming of age or falling from grace
15 June 2012
Neutered Ombudsman Law
11 June 2012
Profiling Erdoğan through the eyes of a confidant
8 June 2012
Whistleblowers and secret recordings in Turkey
4 June 2012
Cost of Syrian crisis to Turkish economy
1 June 2012
THY and union zealots
28 May 2012
The legacy of the Mexican presidency of the G-20
25 May 2012
Turkey and Mexico: Distant yet so close
21 May 2012
İşbank and the CHP
18 May 2012
Erbakan's legacy and gas deal with Iran
14 May 2012
EU-Turkey fundamentals: How strong are they?
11 May 2012
Germany must come clean on neo-Nazi murders
7 May 2012
Davutoğlu's record on parliamentary queries
4 May 2012
Turkish concern over specter of Alawite state in Syria
30 April 2012
Turkey disengages from Iran
27 April 2012
Kayseri: Home to Turkey's best entrepreneurs
23 April 2012
Turkish diplomat turned OIC into force to be reckoned with
20 April 2012
The making of Turkey and Gabon partnership
16 April 2012
France faces blowback for Sarkozy’s fight with Turkey
13 April 2012
Turkey monitors Syria's chemical weapons
9 April 2012
Turkey sorts out legal issues for military action in Syria
6 April 2012
Turkey’s maritime laws and IMO conventions
2 April 2012
Turkey's deficit with China and global implications
30 March 2012
Turkey and China amid the Syrian crisis
26 March 2012
Turkey prepares for partition of Iraq
23 March 2012
Security agreement between Iran and Turkey
19 March 2012
Turkey and Montenegro: Two best examples in Balkans
16 March 2012
Turkey on the IMF quota and governance reforms
12 March 2012
Turkey takes fight to Iran over Iraqi south
9 March 2012
Unleashing people power in Somalia
2 March 2012
State secrets and Turkish press
27 February 2012
Iran's intense interest in Turkey
24 February 2012
ECtHR deals blow to Ergenekon terror
20 February 2012
Fallout from Syrian colonel’s abduction
17 February 2012
No appetite for real media reforms
13 February 2012
Judicial scrutiny of Turkey's spy agency
10 February 2012
Private debt stock in Turkey
6 February 2012
Is Turkey a risk to the international financial system?
3 February 2012
Cover-up over neo-Nazi murders in Germany
30 January 2012
Risk at Turkey’s borders with Iran